Analysis of the STF decision on outsourcing and recognition of employment relationships

Recently, Minister Cármen Lúcia, of the Federal Supreme Court (STF), overturned a decision by the 58th Labor Court of São Paulo that recognized the employment relationship between a driver and the company ETM Transporte e Logística Eireli.
The first instance decision had considered the service provision contract entered into between the company and the driver through a legal entity to be invalid, contradicting the understandings consolidated by the STF on the legality of outsourcing.

Recognition of employment relationship: STF suspends proceedings throughout the country

The Federal Supreme Court (STF) has ordered the suspension of all ongoing proceedings in the country that discuss the recognition of employment relationships in service provision contracts.
The decision was made in Extraordinary Appeal with Appeal No. 1,532,603, which discusses the legality of hiring self-employed workers or those hired through a legal entity, the jurisdiction of the Labor Court in these cases and the burden of proof regarding the allegation of fraud.
The measure aims to ensure uniformity of decisions and legal certainty, and remains valid until the final judgment on the matter.

The impacts of Tax Reform on the real estate sector

Our partner, André de Ataide, gave an interview to the Mídia Oficial portal to comment on the main impacts of the Tax Reform on the real estate sector, focusing on the new rules brought by Complementary Law No. 214/2025.

TST recognizes caregiver's default due to nine-minute delay in virtual hearing: the importance of punctuality in judicial proceedings

The Superior Labor Court (TST) upheld a decision recognizing the default of an elderly caregiver due to a nine-minute delay in entering a virtual evidentiary hearing, resulting in the application of a fictitious confession in favor of the opposing party. The decision reinforces that punctuality is essential in virtual hearings, as per article 844 of the Consolidation of Labor Laws (CLT), which provides for default in the event of the claimant's absence. Although case law has relaxed minimum delays in some cases, the TST strictly followed the law, emphasizing the importance of strict adherence to timetables. The recommendation for workers and lawyers is to arrive at hearings at least 15 minutes early to avoid setbacks and procedural losses.

Possibility of Extrajudicial Compulsory Adjudication

By Vitor Antony Ferrari, Ivan Kubala and Nicoly Crepaldi Minchuerri* In order to ensure greater legal security for the purchase, sale and registration of real estate, the legislator chose to adopt a legal mechanism that allows the registration of real estate even if it is not accompanied by all the required documentation: compulsory adjudication. It is common for […]

STJ excludes ICMS-ST from the PIS and COFINS calculation bases

In November, the Supreme Federal Court (STF) heard ADIs 7,066, 7,070, and 7,078, which discussed the correct timing for states to collect ICMS-Difal. The issue was well-known among taxpayers, many of whom appealed to the courts to avoid collection of the tax […]

MTE Ordinance brings new rules and requires attention to detail

By Rafael Mello and Israel Cruz The Ministry of Labor and Employment (MTE) published Ordinance 3,784 MTE, effective January 2, 2024, introducing significant changes to labor legislation. This ordinance revises and updates Ordinance 671 MTP of 2021, covering important aspects of labor inspection. One of the main changes […]